Snapshots Presents
Bucktown: The Battle for the Soul of Davenport
Special | 28m 30sVideo has Closed Captions
Learn the seedy past of Davenport, IA
Do you know about the seedy past of Davenport? How did so many disreputable businesses in one location? Did someone really say "if I had a choice between Davenport and Hell, I'd take Hell"? This series is made in partnership with Jared Howe, creator of Forgotten Quad Cities. To see more videos like these follow Forgotten Quad Cities on Facebook. Follow WQPT everywhere: @wqptpbs
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Snapshots Presents is a local public television program presented by WQPT PBS
Snapshots Presents
Bucktown: The Battle for the Soul of Davenport
Special | 28m 30sVideo has Closed Captions
Do you know about the seedy past of Davenport? How did so many disreputable businesses in one location? Did someone really say "if I had a choice between Davenport and Hell, I'd take Hell"? This series is made in partnership with Jared Howe, creator of Forgotten Quad Cities. To see more videos like these follow Forgotten Quad Cities on Facebook. Follow WQPT everywhere: @wqptpbs
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch Snapshots Presents
Snapshots Presents is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Snapshots presents Forgotten Quad Cities.
In this episode, you'll learn about Bucktown and the battle for the soul of Davenport.
On a Saturday night at the turn of the 20th century, the east end of downtown Davenport did not sleep.
Gas lights flickered along streets crowded with river men, railroad workers, factory laborers, traveling performers, gamblers, and local young men looking for excitement.
Piano music spilled through open doors.
Brass bands played in beer halls and theaters.
Dice rattled across tabletops, glasses struck wooden bars from the Mississippi River to the blocks around East second Street.
The night moved to the sound of music, money and drink.
This was Bucktown.
It was only a small part of Davenport, but its reputation traveled far beyond Iowa.
Newspapers and reformers described the city as one of the most wicked places in America.
A visitor from Chicago called it the toughest town in the country, and claimed that Chicago seemed like paradise by comparison.
One minister declared that if he owned both Hell and Davenport, he would sell Davenport and keep hell.
The citizens of Davenport heard the accusations, but they kept the saloons open anyway.
At its height, Bucktown contained an extraordinary concentration of bars, gambling rooms, music halls, theaters, and brothels.
Some accounts placed more than 40 houses of prostitution within only a few blocks.
Saloons stood almost shoulder to shoulder.
In the busiest rooms, the games and drinking continued through the night and into the following morning.
Yet Bucktown was never simply a collection of dark rooms and dangerous streets.
It was also a highbrow center of music, theater, and immigrant life.
Opera could be heard only blocks from burlesque.
German families gathered in beer gardens while professional gamblers worked nearby.
Symphony musicians, vaudeville performer, sex workers, businessmen, reformers and laborers all moved through the same compact neighborhood.
High culture and low culture existed side by side in Bucktown.
They grew from the same city.
To understand how Bucktown came to be.
We need to go back to decades earlier, to the thousands of German immigrants who transformed Davenport in the middle of the 19th century.
The first German families reached the Davenport area while the city was still young.
Immigration accelerated in the late 1840s and early 1850s, when political upheaval and war pushed thousands of people out of the German states and the disputed region of Schleswig-Holstein.
Some were the men and women later called the Fourty-Eighters Supporters of the democratic revolutions that swept across Europe in 1848 and 1849.
They had demanded constitutional government, civil rights, and political reform.
When those revolutions failed, many faced prison, economic hardship and a return to governments they had tried to overthrow.
America offered safety, land and a new start.
Davenport was well positioned to receive them.
Immigrants could cross the Atlantic, travel inland, and board steamboats at New Orleans or Saint Louis.
From there, the Mississippi carried them north to a growing river city, surrounded by rich farmland and hungry for craftsmen, merchants, and laborers.
But Davenport offered something else that mattered just as much: other Germans.
The immigrants already living there wrote home and encouraged relatives, neighbors, and friends to follow.
A chain of migration formed.
In early 1848 alone, one group of roughly 250 immigrants, many from Schleswig-Holstein, arrived in Davenport.
After the struggle against Danish rule collapsed, the migration became larger.
Through the 1850s, German families continued to step from riverboats onto the Davenport levee.
By 1890, nearly one quarter of the people living in Scott County had been born in Germany.
Davenport became one of the most heavily German cities in the United States.
German was spoken in homes, stores, and government offices.
It appeared in newspapers and was taught in schools.
German families organized singing societies, gymnastic clubs, veterans groups, theatrical companies and political associations.
They established churches, open businesses and built some of Davenport's most important institutions.
They also brought a view of public life that was often very different from the one held by Iowa's Protestant reformers.
Many of the immigrants believe strongly in education, music, art, and political freedom.
They carried the secular, democratic spirit of the failed European revolutions.
They tended to be suspicious of anyone who tried to dictate private behavior.
They also brought beer.
In the German communities of Davenport, drinking beer was not considered a moral failing.
It was part of meals, festivals and family gatherings.
Beer gardens were places where families went together to eat, listen to music, and visit with their neighbors.
That difference in outlook placed Davenport on a collision course with the rest of Iowa.
For much of the 19th and early 20th centuries, Iowa politics was shaped by the struggle between the wets and the dries.
Those who wanted alcohol to remain legal and available, and those who wanted to outlaw all drinking.
The dries included Protestant ministers, temperance organizations, and reformers who viewed alcohol as the source of poverty, crime, domestic violence, and social decay.
They believed that limiting liquor was not enough.
It had to be prohibited.
The wets opposed statewide prohibition.
They believed local communities should decide the question without interference from Des Moines.
In heavily German Davenport, opposition to prohibition became part of the city's identity.
Few places in Iowa were wetter than Davenport.
When the state attempted to enforce prohibition, Davenport often refused to cooperate.
Local officials had little enthusiasm for closing businesses, supported by a large share of the population.
Saloons continued to operate.
Beer continued to flow.
Laws passed in Des Moines encountered a different reality when they reached Bucktown.
In 1894, Iowa adopted what became known as the Mulct Law.
It allowed communities to tolerate saloons under strict conditions if their operators paid a large tax.
It was a compromise.
Prohibition remained on the books, while saloons paid for the privilege of violating it.
Davenport embraced the arrangement.
The city collected substantial revenue from saloons and other tolerated businesses.
The money helped pay for streets, sewers, and municipal expenses.
It also helped Davenport retire the debt on its new city hall.
At one point, income from licenses, taxes, and fines became so important that the city was able to operate without collecting a municipal property tax.
The arrangement revealed the contradiction at the center of Davenport.
Activities condemned as sinful by reformers were helping finance local government.
The city didn't just tolerate its wide open reputation.
It built civic life around the money that reputation produced.
And nowhere was that bargain more visible than in Bucktown.
Bucktown occupied the eastern edge of downtown, close to the river, railroad lines, hotels and theaters.
Its location made it a natural destination for people passing through the city.
Steamboat crews came ashore with wages in their pockets.
Railroad workers and factory laborers arrived after long shifts.
Traveling salesmen, soldiers, and performers mixed with local customers.
The origin of the name has never been settled with certainty, but one popular explanation connected it to the young bucks, who patronized the district's saloons and brothels.
Whatever its origin, the name came to represent a place where Davenport's ordinary rules disappeared after dark.
At the bar, a river man could spend in a few hours what had taken him weeks to earn.
In a gambling room, cards might remain on the table for days.
Farrow, poker and other games drew professional gamblers from cities up and down the Mississippi.
Men won fortunes lost paychecks and signed handwritten markers promising to settle their debts later.
Some riverboat captains understood Bucktown's pull well enough to delay paying crews until after their boats had left Davenport.
A man who received his wages too soon might spend everything, lose his boots, or simply fail to return before departure.
The district could be dangerous, exploitative and cruel.
Its economy depended on appetites and inequalities that were rarely discussed.
Men generally moved through Bucktown with far more freedom than women.
The women who worked in its brothels lived under public scrutiny, police control and the constant threat of violence, poverty, and arrest.
But Bucktown was also a working class neighborhood with its own forms of loyalty.
Saloon served as informal banks, employment offices, and relief agencies.
A bartender might know who was hiring on the river, which family needed coal, or which regular had not eaten.
Credit was sometimes extended without paperwork.
During layoffs or hard winters, a neighborhood saloon could feed people whom respectable Davenport preferred not to see.
One of Bucktown's legendary figures was James A.
(Brick) Monroe.
An entertainment kingpin known throughout Davenport as the King of Bucktown, whose nickname came from his shock of red hair.
His empire centered on Brick Monroe's Pavilion and Summer garden at the southwest corner of Second and Rock Island Streets, now Pershing Avenue.
Monroe owned seven theaters, a pool hall, a livery stable, and Davenport's first motorized taxi service.
His pavilion offered drinking, dancing, and live entertainment.
A young singing bartender named Al Jolson performed there before becoming one of the 20th century's biggest stars.
Despite operating amid Buck town's gambling rooms and brothels, Monroe refused to allow prostitutes to solicit customers inside his establishment.
He was also known for keeping a mental ledger, extending credit to customers who had fallen on hard times, and rarely refusing anyone who asked him for money.
Much of that money, which was in the thousands of dollars, was never repaid.
Brick didn't seem to mind.
The most controversial part of Davenport's experiment was prostitution.
In 1893, Mayor Henry Vollmer announced that the city would regulate prostitution rather than pretend it could eliminate it.
For roughly the next 16 years, Davenport operated a system that amounted to municipal licensing of brothels.
Brothel operators paid regular fines or fees.
Women working in the houses were registered and subjected to medical examinations.
City directories sometimes concealed brothels beneath labels such as boarding houses, but their existence was hardly a secret.
The policy reflected ideas common in parts of Europe.
City leaders argued that prostitution would exist whether it was legal or not.
Regulation, they believed, would contain it within a known district, limit the spread of disease, and protect respectable households from the behavior of men.
That logic placed nearly all responsibility on women while quietly accepting the conduct of their male customers.
It also gave the government extraordinary power over the bodies and movements of working class women.
A woman could be examined, fined, jailed or driven from one part of the city to another.
While the men who purchased sex usually remained anonymous.
Davenport's policy was unusual enough to attract national attention.
The city chose management over suppression.
In the eyes of reformers, it was proof that local government had joined forces with evil.
In the eyes of the German American mayor and his supporters, it was realism.
The system lasted through changes in city government because it was profitable and consistent with the city's resistance to outside control.
It ended in 1909 after changes in state law made the policy impossible to continue.
Like the battle over alcohol, the battle over prostitution was about who had the authority to define morality in Davenport.
Was it the state legislature, the church reformers, the police voters, or the city itself?
For generations, Davenport's answer remained the same.
It believed it knew better than outsiders what was right for its citizens.
Bucktowns notoriety can obscure another part of its history.
The district was not only where Davenport went to drink, gamble and purchased sex.
It was also where the city went to be entertained.
German immigrants placed music and art near the center of community life.
Singing societies, marching bands and orchestras were not luxuries reserved for the wealthy.
They were part of the culture of ordinary people.
A laborer might spend the day in a factory; in the evening, singing in a chorus, playing in a band, or listening to an operatic performance.
Davenport possessed theaters before it possessed many of the public services later generations would consider basic.
The Burtis Opera House opened near Bucktown in 1867, with room for a large audience and an imposing interior.
It welcomed touring actors, lecturers and musicians.
Mark Twain spoke there.
Susan B Anthony appeared there.
The building represented Davenport's ambition to be more than a raw industrial river town, and the new Tri-City Symphony Orchestra, precursor to today's Quad City Symphony, debuted at Burtis in May 1916.
At the same time, less respectable stages flourished.
Nearby music halls offered comedy, variety acts, burlesque, and performances too provocative for more conventional theaters.
Touring entertainers learned quickly that Bucktown audiences could be loud, impatient, and brutally honest.
An act that held the attention of a crowded room there could hold an audience almost anywhere.
Music moved freely between these worlds.
German bands played marches and concert music.
Ragtime pianists and early jazz musicians worked in saloons, dance halls, and theaters.
Popular songs crossed racial, ethnic, and social boundaries, even when the people performing them could not do so safely.
A Young Bix Beiderbeck grew up in Davenport while this musical culture was still alive.
He came from a respectable German-American family, but the new sounds emerging from the riverfront fascinated him.
The music of black musicians traveling the Mississippi, the syncopated rhythms of ragtime and the freedom of jazz offered something different from the formal music expected in polite homes.
Bix would eventually carry Davenport's name into jazz history.
One of his best known compositions was called Davenport Blues.
His story belonged to a city where the distance between the concert hall and the saloon was only a few blocks.
That was Bucktowns great contradiction.
The district's high and low culture were not opposites.
They depended on the same immigrant belief that art, music, leisure and public gathering belonged in everyday life.
The opera house and the beer garden, the symphony and the dance hall, the brass band and the ragtime piano all emerged from a city that wanted all of it.
And Bucktown reigned as an entertainment epicenter.
To Davenport's reformers, the music could not drown out the suffering.
Temperance advocates saw wages disappearing in saloons while families went hungry.
Ministers saw women exploited in brothels and children growing up beside gambling rooms.
Middle class women entered public life through reform organizations, arguing that the consequences of male vice did not remain inside Bucktown.
Reformers described their campaign as a battle between good and evil.
They demanded raids, closures, and stricter enforcement.
They pressured state officials when local police refused to act.
Newspapers on both sides portrayed the conflict as a fight for the soul of Davenport.
The other side did not see itself as evil.
Saloon keepers defended their livelihoods.
German voters defended their customs.
Laborers defended the places where they gathered after work.
City officials defended local authority in the revenue that kept taxes low.
Some believed vice was inevitable and that regulation was safer than hypocrisy.
The result was a long civic standoff.
When pressure from Des Moines became intense, police sometimes conducted raids.
Yet enforcement was selective.
Owners received warnings.
Arrests were made, fines were paid, and business resumed.
The fine functioned less like punishment and more like just the cost of operating.
That pattern deepened the reformers anger.
Davenport appeared to obey the law while protecting the businesses the law was supposed to destroy.
Each side accused the other of bad faith.
Reformers spoke of rescuing the city.
Their opponents heard outsiders trying to erase their culture.
By the first decade of the 20th century, the balance began to shift.
State government tightened its control.
Davenport system of regulated prostitution ended in 1909.
Gambling faced greater pressure.
Saloons became harder to protect.
Bucktown did not disappear at once, but the wide open arrangement that had sustained it began to weaken.
Then the First World War transformed the conflict.
When the United States entered the war against Germany in 1917, Davenport's German heritage became a source of suspicion.
Families who had lived in Iowa for generations found their loyalty questioned.
German books were removed from schools.
German language newspapers lost readers and advertisers.
Churches faced pressure to abandon German services.
Music, food and traditions once celebrated as part of Davenport's identity were recast as evidence of foreign allegiance.
In 1918, Iowa Governor William Harding issued what became known as the Babel Proclamation.
It directed that English be used in schools, religious gatherings, and public conversations.
Speaking to a neighbor in the language of one's parents could now be treated as unpatriotic.
For Germans in Davenport, the humiliation ran deep.
Many had ancestors who fled authoritarian governments in Europe.
Many had fought for the Union during the Civil War.
Now their language and culture were being policed by their own state.
At nearly the same moment, the dries finally achieved their greatest victory.
National prohibition took effect in 1920.
The saloons, now outlawed, completely closed breweries stopped producing beer.
The German beer gardens that had anchored Davenport social life disappeared.
The wet culture that had resisted Iowa for decades had been outlawed by the United States Constitution.
The old Bucktown was already fading before prohibition arrived, but the new law closed the door completely on the world that had created it.
What remained moved underground.
The city's informal system of tolerance gave way to a harsher contest between federal enforcement and criminal enterprise.
The forces that once met openly in Bucktown now moved into politics.
In the spring of 1920, Davenport voters shocked Iowa by electing a socialist mayor.
Doctor C.L.
Berwald was a local physician and the son of German immigrants.
He was not an image of violent revolution.
He was a familiar community doctor, speaking to voters who believed the established parties had abandoned them.
German Americans had particular reasons to be angry.
Democrats had been associated with the wartime government that questioned their loyalty.
Republicans were closely identified with prohibition.
Workers were confronting unemployment, rising prices, and industrial uncertainty.
The Socialist Party offered a place where those grievances could meet.
Socialism also had roots in the political traditions carried by some German immigrants.
The 48-ers had believed that government could serve ordinary citizens.
In industrial cities such as Milwaukee, German-American socialists promoted practical municipal reforms better streets, public utilities, sanitation, parks, and honest government.
Berwald had nearly won the mayor's office in 1918, losing by only 25 votes.
When he ran again in 1920, the result was decisive.
He won by more than 1600 votes.
Five of Davenport's eight aldermen were elected on the Socialist ticket, along with candidates for other municipal offices.
The timing was peculiar.
The Russian Revolution was only three years old.
The United States was in the grip of the first Red scare.
Federal agents were raiding radical organizations, and newspapers warned that Bolshevism threatened the nation.
Yet Davenport placed much of its city government in socialist hands.
The voters were not necessarily demanding a revolution.
Many wanted streets repaired, sewers extended, jobs created, and schools improved.
They wanted free textbooks and better pay for teachers.
They were eager to punish the parties responsible for wartime nativism and prohibition.
Barrels victory was the political expression of its immigrant population that had spent generations resisting people who wanted to tell it how to live.
But the coalition quickly fractured.
Berwald was more moderate than several socialist aldermen.
Disputes over spending, appointm Barely eight months after taking office, the mayor left the Socialist Party, though he remained in office.
Then came one of the strangest episodes in Davenport political history.
In 1921, Berwald noticed marks on a chandelier above his desk in City Hall.
Investigators discovered a crude listening device hidden inside it with wires running into the ceiling.
The trail led to a receiver concealed in the attic.
The city electrician admitted installing the device on the orders of a socialist alderman.
The scandal consumed the administration.
The five socialist councilmen were mocked as the Frantic Five.
Accusations moved in every direction, and the promise of practical reform dissolved into factional warfare.
In 1922, Berwald ran for reelection as a Democrat and lost.
Davenport Socialist government was over by the time Berwald left City Hall.
The Davenport that had elected him was already passing away.
The old brothel licensing system was gone.
Prohibition had closed the legal saloons.
German was heard less often in public.
Automobiles altered the geography of downtown, and businesses connected to the new motor industry moved into parts of the old Bucktown district.
Later, redevelopment erased buildings and changed the street patterns that had once concentrated so much life into so few blocks.
The card rooms emptied, the brothels closed or moved.
The gas lights went dark.
The saloon doors that never closed were finally shut.
It was a place where women were exploited, and where women also found ways to survive in a society, offering them few economic choices.
It was a place where workers lost wages and where hungry people were sometimes fed.
It was a place of drunkenness, disease and corruption, but also of music, theater, immigrant fellowship and artistic experimentation.
Above all, Bucktown was where Davenport's arguments became visible.
Who had the right to define a city's morals?
Could vice be eliminated or only managed?
Did reform protect families, or did it become a weapon against immigrants and working people?
Where did personal freedom end and public responsibility begin?
Was culture something that belonged in an opera house?
Or could it also be found in a crowded saloon when a pianist began to play?
Bucktown doesn't offer simple answers, but Bucktown story did not end there.
Over the past several decades, many of its historic buildings have found new life as bars, restaurants, shops, entertainment venues, and modern loft apartments that preserve their architectural character.
Together with the neighboring Motor Row Historic District, Bucktown has again become a center of commerce, entertainment, and downtown living.
Driven by the work of the Downtown Davenport Partnership and the business owners who invested in its revival.
Along Second Street, great River brewery, the Last Picture House, Mississippi River Distilling Companies Downtown Lounge, Bucktown Lofts, Half Nelson, The Raccoon Motel, and Ragged Records have brought people back to blocks that once seemed forgotten.
On Third Street, the Hotel Black Hawk and Adler Theater blend their historic elegance with contemporary comforts.
Bucktown lofts carries a particularly meaningful connection to the neighborhood's past.
The four story building, constructed in 1915 on the former site of brick Monroe's famous pavilion, later became the Bucktown Center for the Arts.
Home to numerous galleries and studios before being transformed into apartments nearby, a lighted archway bearing the names Bucktown and Motor Row now welcomes visitors to Emerson Place, where colorful public art fills the alley.
In Bucktown, everything old is new again.
The buildings have changed.
The crowds are different, but the questions that once divided Davenport remained familiar.
Who belongs, whose culture counts, and who has the power to decide how everyone else should live?
That may be Bucktown's most enduring legacy.
Beneath the music, vice and spectacle was a city struggling to define itself a struggle over morality, freedom and who had the right to shape Davenport's future.
The old Bucktown disappeared.
The argument at its heart never did.
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.
New Episode- Drama

Benjamin Wainwright stars as Maigret in the contemporary adaptation of Georges Simenon's novels.
New Episode
Recently Added
New Episode







Support for PBS provided by:
Snapshots Presents is a local public television program presented by WQPT PBS